Question:
Do you think the James Foley beheading is real or fake?
Belinda N
2014-08-21 11:31:58 UTC
I think it is fake. I watched the whole video. It does not seem to be real to me. Why would James Foley be so calm if he knew he was getting beheaded? Why would they black out the beheading portion? Why is there no blood at the beginning portion when the guy in black supposedly is cutting his neck? What do you all think?
Eighteen answers:
damian k
2014-08-21 12:51:47 UTC
FAKE. When extremist was shown with 2nd hostage, he had no blood on him. Knife in fake photo is not the fake knife in the video. No blood after a few slices. Also, there would have been other men hollering "allah akbar". The beheading was not shown. Don't be so quick to believe it. James Foley went to the other side and helped produce this fraud. He is a photo journalist.
maxscs
2014-08-24 13:12:32 UTC
I say "fake".

These days I tried to find out as much as possible. Far be it from me to encourage or condone in any way the Islamic terrorism, but the James Foley's beheading is absolutely a fake.

The proposed video on the net, even in full version, does not reveal any beheading. It's an impressive video: too much. Done artfully: all too. The fading intervenes to cut out the gruesome part or the hardest part to simulate or fake. The video does not reveal the substance.

Why there is no call to Islam? Not even an "Allah Akbhar"? In the name of who or what Foley had to be beheaded?

Think about it: the alleged Executioner says nothing. He must kill Foley only because he is "from your Country, Obama". This, ladies and gentlemen, is simply idiotic.

According to which right has been carried out an execution in death? And indeed ... where is the face of death?

Nick Berg 2007 vs Foley 2014. Make a comparison between the two executions and find the fake, if you dare. It's pretty difficult having courage when you play with fear. To have courage you to have a thirst for truth.
ixcotoyac
2016-10-06 16:17:40 UTC
Real Beheading
anonymous
2014-08-22 13:05:40 UTC
Yes it James foley beheading is very fake ...Here are some arguments about the video http://cnyakundi.com/is-james-foley-beheading-video-fake-read-a-testimony-here/
diggs wembley
2014-08-23 12:27:16 UTC
The neck cut in the "death" picture looks too straight. I enlarged the image, and the head has a lot of pixels, but most other areas do not. I think the entire process would have been filmed up close and personal for maximum impact had it been genuine. The interview with the parents puzzles me. I would personally have never been able to face reporters and go on and on about things so soon after getting the "confirmation" of his death.
Honest
2014-08-21 16:55:01 UTC
If the James Foley family is convinced they and I will not appreciate being mocked.
MAT
2014-08-21 23:05:30 UTC
It's fake people! It's so fake it's bordering on ridiculous! Wake up America, there is an agenda that is being fulfilled right now. Can't anyone see thru all the bullshit? Stop watching the controlled mainstream media and look into independent media, our media is a joke!!!!
anonymous
2014-08-22 11:57:14 UTC
He was actually killed by beheading . Here is the Full Video showing the ISIS BEHEADING HIM http://cnyakundi.com/here-is-the-video-of-isis-beheading-american-journalist-james-foley-24/
Brother Hesekiel
2014-08-21 11:54:51 UTC
Hard to say 'cause we never see the real footage. Same with Osama Bin Laden. Conveniently buried at sea as to not to offend the non-existent Islamic god of terror.



We're asked to have faith in what we're being served is real. In that respect the US government and ISIS are on the same level.
Captain dragon
2014-08-21 19:23:20 UTC
Why would it be fake????? There is a theory that foley did not know he would die until the moment arrived
broke with smelly dogs
2014-08-22 12:49:35 UTC
only thing I can think explains the mellow foley, not struggling and happy to be beheaded (not even his voice was nervous) IF and big IF this is real.....is because he gave himself to Allah and allowed himself to die, sacrificed himself to degrade USA and say those things about the USA
jleebesaw
2014-08-21 17:12:49 UTC
i just saw it too. it seemed like it was edited. their voices sounded like they were recorded in a studio, not on a hill with high winds. i dont know, man. i have seen other beheadings on best gore, and this one seemed too "clean". there wasnt much blood around the body at the end compared to the other beheading videos i have seen.
houston
2014-08-21 11:39:16 UTC
I THINK OBAMA CLAIMING TO HAVE SENT IN SPECIAL

FORCES TO RESCUE THE HOSTAGES ON THE DAY

AFTER THE BEHEADING IS A COVER HIS *** BOLD

FACED LIE ..!!
anonymous
2014-08-21 20:04:54 UTC
it might be fake. they probably just killed him offscreen. only disgusting sickos would behead him in front of a camera and post it on youtube. well actually, who knows?
towwwdothello
2014-08-21 11:40:38 UTC
I think it's real, and I also think they should proceed with as much caution considering interests, as possible. Something that horrific is hard to believe.
anonymous
2014-08-21 11:33:38 UTC
What do you think, David Copperfield did a show for the terrorists? Yes it is real. Go there and check it out.
bassplayinlady
2014-08-22 00:13:09 UTC
the only thing I didn't understand was it shows 1-3 seconds of his throat getting cut, hard and fast, but not a single drop of blood is shed.
Chris B
2014-09-09 16:28:51 UTC
It's real. He didn't think they would actually do it.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...